I don't really fish this way often, but I'm wondering about why people would advocate longer sink tips in a casting from boat situation. Im imagining its on the move, targeting cut banks and boulders and overhangs that require quickness as much as accuracy. I think id be inclined to use a short, fast sinking tip and a weighted fly. I feel like a long sink tip is gonna cost you agility when that target opens up. Picking it up and putting it down as quickly as possible should probably be a consideration?
If swinging broad runs, long tips and unweighted flies all day. But for having 5 seconds to identify the target and need to strip, lift and fire? All for 2 or 3 strips? A longer tip doesn't seem like much of a benefit there