Trout streamers from a boat?

Weighted fly on a floating line or unweighted fly on a sinktip?

  • Weighted

    Votes: 3 50.0%
  • Unweighted

    Votes: 3 50.0%

  • Total voters
    6

Scudley Do Right

Legend
Forum Supporter
I only go river fishing in MT once or twice a year. I just picked up a sink tip streamer line but I'm wondering what most people do? Do you fish heavily weighted flies on a floating line or unweighted files on a sinktip? I was thinking the unweighted flies and sinktip would be nicer to cast. I don't know if one is more effective than the other though.
 
Actually from a moving drift boat weighted fly, short leader, floating or sinktip line. You only have a second for the fly to drop into the zone while the boat is moving 5ft/sec.. If using boat for access and wading then unweighted fly because I like more action on unweighted fly and have time for line management to help control depth and presentation.
 
I’ve made a great many commercial drift boat/raft floats on the Yellowstone (Paradise Valley and the lower Livingston to Columbus section), Madison, and Big Hole (multiple sections from Divide to the mouth) and Jefferson (upper section) Over the last 20 years. When fishing streamers it is always a large (2-5”) unweighted streamer on a long sink tip (usually Sonar 25/30 cold) with a short (3-4’), stout tippet (OX). Long, accurate casts are possible covering a lot of water and precise targeting of bank-side undercuts and seams possible as boats tend to not necessarily follow a smooth path downstream.

The real advantage to the unweighted fly and short tippet is it is much safer and less prone to errant casts in a crowded boat. When floating with a partner I much prefer the back seat as it opens up more water on every cast.
 
It depends. Most of my trout streamers are weighted. I like the jiggy action they impart, but I don't like 'em real heavy, for the obvious casting reasons. Sometimes a floating line, but usually a sink tip. I have a couple of newer very fast sinking tip lines that work really well for this purpose. The weighted fly and sink tip make for a good presentation into that hold by a stump, log jam, or boulder. It's only going to take 1, 2, or 3 strips before the strike comes. This is possibly my favorite way for fall trout fishing.
 
If I'm swinging a big run w/ the boat anchored, I tend to prefer unweighted and let the tip get it down. Feels like I get less snags at the tail end of the run w/ an unweighted swing.

If I'm stripping, I tend to prefer weighted for the reason @Salmo_g mentioned.

If i'm throwing streamers at a bucket/targeted location, I usually use weighted as those spots typically require as quick a decent as possible.
 
When I finally switched over to a short 3 - 4ft leader it made all the difference! That was years ago on the Madison with a 20 ft sink tip.
 
I'm in the unweight camp when fishing streamers. Just find it more pleasant to fish then that way. Depending on the streamer size and the fish being targeted I typically fish 150 grain or 250 grain sink tip (something in the 20-foot range) and a relatively short leader. Retrieve with aggressive strips and use a strip set on the take, I have found that those predatory fish will come and get a presented streamer often moving several feet to do so.

In fact, I have expanded my streamer game far beyond just targeting trout. With adjustments in flies and water fished have had success with the above approach on sea-run cutthroat, bull trout, steelhead, and various salmon species. Over the last 30 years other than some summer skated dry flies all my steelhead fly fishing has been with unweighted streamers.

Curt
 
I don't really fish this way often, but I'm wondering about why people would advocate longer sink tips in a casting from boat situation. Im imagining its on the move, targeting cut banks and boulders and overhangs that require quickness as much as accuracy. I think id be inclined to use a short, fast sinking tip and a weighted fly. I feel like a long sink tip is gonna cost you agility when that target opens up. Picking it up and putting it down as quickly as possible should probably be a consideration?

If swinging broad runs, long tips and unweighted flies all day. But for having 5 seconds to identify the target and need to strip, lift and fire? All for 2 or 3 strips? A longer tip doesn't seem like much of a benefit there
 
I don't really fish this way often, but I'm wondering about why people would advocate longer sink tips in a casting from boat situation. Im imagining its on the move, targeting cut banks and boulders and overhangs that require quickness as much as accuracy. I think id be inclined to use a short, fast sinking tip and a weighted fly. I feel like a long sink tip is gonna cost you agility when that target opens up. Picking it up and putting it down as quickly as possible should probably be a consideration?

If swinging broad runs, long tips and unweighted flies all day. But for having 5 seconds to identify the target and need to strip, lift and fire? All for 2 or 3 strips? A longer tip doesn't seem like much of a benefit there
You can’t fish long as effectively with a short tip but you can effectively fish short with a long tip. When floating, there are usually opportunities for both, and a long sink tip is more versatile than a short one. Indeed the caster has to anticipate and adjust on the move as the distance from the boat to the bank or structure is rarely ever constant.

This brown was nailed in about 6” of bank side water only 15’ away from the boat. Five weight XP with SA Streamer Express (30’ tip) 150 grain. Didn’t even need to get the whole tip out of the guides.

IMG_00267.jpeg
 
Being from Western Washington and fishing on the beach most of the time I definitely struggle with the shorter casts. I bought a streamer max short in hopes it's a little easier to cast with minimal line out.
 
Being from Western Washington and fishing on the beach most of the time I definitely struggle with the shorter casts. I bought a streamer max short in hopes it's a little easier to cast with minimal line out.

A concentrated head might make that worse. A concentrated head for say a 5wt rod is 2 rod weights heavy to lift a bigger payload further like beach casting a heavy fly into the wind. When drifting in a boat different opportunities present. You might throw streamers all day but you might get into dryfly water too. So you want to have rods rigged or be able to convert with little fanfan. A simple DT or WF line rated for the rod is really all you need drifting and casting those shorter ranges and throws everything from bobbers to streamers. A typical WF line is cast 30-40ft because that's it's sweet spot. Too short or too long is just harder to do. Can you cast 100ft with WF line? Yes but it's a lot easier with different tools.
 
@Scudley Do Right , the Streamer Max Short is my last line that I'd be grabbing for from the beach. A distance line it is not. Where I love it is for fishing big weightless bull trout flies for relatively short casts (typically within 50') in jungle water....and stuff like that.

I used to use it some for tiger muskies (and it fishes very well), but prefer a slightly longer head for that type of work.
 
Last edited:
@Scudley Do Right , the Streamer Max Short is my last line that I'd be grabbing for from the beach. A distance line it is not. Where I love it is for fishing big weightless bull trout flies for relatively short casts (typically within 50') in jungle water....and stuff like that.

I used to use it some for tiger muskies (and it fishes very well), but prefer a slightly longer head for that type of work.
I got it for what you described. I was gonna try it in the river from the boat. I like a 40plus off the beach.
 
I got it for what you described. I was gonna try it in the river from the boat. I like a 40plus off the beach.
ahhhhh, I think I inserted 'beach' somewhere in there when I read your post (no idea why)...lol.
 
A concentrated head might make that worse. A concentrated head for say a 5wt rod is 2 rod weights heavy to lift a bigger payload further like beach casting a heavy fly into the wind. When drifting in a boat different opportunities present. You might throw streamers all day but you might get into dryfly water too. So you want to have rods rigged or be able to convert with little fanfan. A simple DT or WF line rated for the rod is really all you need drifting and casting those shorter ranges and throws everything from bobbers to streamers. A typical WF line is cast 30-40ft because that's it's sweet spot. Too short or too long is just harder to do. Can you cast 100ft with WF line? Yes but it's a lot easier with different tools.
I'm used to shooting heads. Even when we are using drys I prefer a floating 40plus. I'll give it a go and see. My thinking was being heavy it might go with only 10-20' out.
 
Back
Top