In defense of the fly fishing club

This will probably come off as a "curmudgeon" so first "get it out my yard!"

2ijiif.jpg

So, a bit of background so you understand when I call BS to some of these comments as I used to when I was young 35-50 and had words with co-workers about this kinda of issue. I grew up fishing River (80%) and Lakes (20%), now it had transitioned to the exact opposite. I am currently 63, I was a single dad for 2 years with full custody, I remarried which added 2 more kids (all boys), worked full time added overtime at times and travel. All the boys played sports, 3 played multiple, two played at advanced levels and on travel teams from cost to cost. 3 were in cub scouts (I as den leader, cub master) and 2 went into boys scouts (I was assistant scoutmaster and then scoutmaster for 11 years). I was a member of two fishing clubs and banquet chair/fund raiser for a local chair of a national fisheries organization. So... I call BS on any younger person that says they don't have the time to join or help. Sorry a married coworker (no kids) said she and her husband just didn't have the time and that was why they had a house keeper... I about lost my sh*t!!! We were the same age. I had two moms drop off boys at scouts saying they would be back after they got done at the gym or yoga class, they were talked to 1 pulled her boy and the other became a great leader!

I have watched and tried to understand why we are seeing clubs, faternal order, volunteer organization, and church's lose numbers. One thing comes up over and over, self not selfless. If you have 1 hour of "free time", what would you do with it, go to the gym etc. or teach a teenager how to tie flies? If you have knowledge to share but don't have access to youth how will you share it? Likewise, if you show up feeling that they are a bunch of grumpy old guys thinking you know it all or your way is the only right way then your approaching it wrong. Show up and ask questions nicely with respectful attitude, then just let the old guys ramble, you can hear a lot of wisdom. Many old guys get tired of young punks with stuck up attitudes, thinking they already know it all.

My wife and I were just having a discussion about volunteers at club meetings, here is the best way to learn and get involved, show up and ask "what can I do to help?" Not, "I am hear to volunteer but I will only do this..." then grumbling about the club or organization not being what they want. We recently had an event that the membership brought forward, the board agreed and provided funding and... then only 4 people (the normal showups and board members) volunteered to man the event, not even those that were pushing the event from the membership. All they were asked to do was show up and help.

Now onto current thinking, there are just way more activities available for kids, families and even old people (think pickleball). That is where we saw the reduction in boy scouts. Also, it seems that if you were not raised to volunteer or join, seeing all the positives, you see it more as work without pay or payoff than an opportunity to learn and grow.

Lastly, I always challenged my Eagle Scout candidates with the following, "As you grow up remember all the adults that volunteered their time, knowledge and equipment to share their knowledge with you, and give you these great experience. So, my challenge to you is for you to give back to the people coming after you and your kids."

I am willing to share even to the point of almost losing fishing/hunting buddies and causing tension within my own family. Because I shared a "secret fly" or "secret spot".

And what is REALLY frustrating is as much technology makes it easy to learn and share, so many of the young people will not even take enough time to send input to WDFW or Olympia (and YES it matters!). And they can do it all from their phones. So don't crybaby about not getting better fishing, access or seasons when all you do is bitch about it online! Get involved.

Stepping off my soap box and advice is free and not all views are approved by management

Me sitting on the porch waiting...

secondhand_lions_403x270.jpg
 
What @clarkman said. I consider this my fly fishing club now and have met up with a few people so far and hopefully more as the years go on.

I’m not a hater on clubs it’s just got to make sense.
I’m in the WA trailblazers club which has a lot of men and women from many age groups and is surpassingly trending on the younger side over the last two years. More of a hikers group then fishing though. They’ve adapted their meetings to have a virtual option which has its pros and cons but I think what helps attract younger people.
 
Why are clubs filled with old people and few young people? My experience:

When I was in my 30’s and 40’s, I was working 50-60 hours a week. When I wasn’t working, I was with my wife and two sons and mainly following their pursuits. My “clubs” were athletic and music spectating and my friends were other parents who I got to know over the years standing on sidelines or sitting in stands. In my 50’s, I was working 50-60 hours a week and re-discovering who my wife was after our kids left to create their own adventures and families.

Now, I no longer work 50-60 hours, so all of my “work family” are off on their own things, and my wife and I are seeking people of similar interests and, voila, “clubs” get formed.

I belonged to no clubs as a younger man, because I didn’t need the social interaction - it just happened through work and kids. Now as an old man, social interaction has to be sought out and nurtured in ways it didn’t require as a younger man. That’s my theory of why there are few younger adults in formal clubs and why they’re typically filled with people…..of a certain age.
 
It's not just the in-person clubs, this forum deals with a similar issue. We have an aging forum user-base with little to no replenishment from the younger generations. I think our youngest usual contributors are mid to late 30s if my estimates are right. Us admins are much younger than our average user, and we're all in our mid 40s.

Younger folks are very much tuned-in to bite-size pieces of info fed to them like a firehose. Their "social" life is through online videogames, TikTok, and other such things. I have a 17yr old and it's been painful to watch as he grows. We've tried, but there's only so much you can do. Thankfully, he's started doing a few in-person activities with some of his friends from school band class.

I don't know that I have solutions, but the problem is absolutely the addictive nature of the online social platforms and the way the internet in general has evolved. Everything is about keeping eyes on the screen and dumping as much at them as possible. Their entire worldview was shaped by this and it's extremely difficult to compete with algorithms specifically designed to hook young people.
I'm only a data point of one, but video games came into being when I was a kid. I'm talking pong, which believe it or not, was amazing when it came out. But I think the internet/social media thing is an extension of what the introduction of video games started. I found that my friends no longer wanted to play hoop, baseball, fish or any other outside activity any longer and just wanted to play video games either at the local mini-mart or at home.
 
I think participation in associations/clubs are a natural fit for those folks who have gregarious personalities and have sufficient discretionary time.

While I have the requisite time I have absolutely no inclination to do so, being quite happy to recreate alone, or in the company of a very few kindred souls.

After a lifetime of meetings, agendas, and projects I'm done with that part of my life.
Now that makes me wonder if it was you on Amber lake as we drifted bs’s, you fishing, my dog watching you fish a couple months ago.
 
I looked into some FF clubs but just determined they weren’t for me.
A bit off topic, but it seems FF clubs tend to have more older folks. I had some dealings with some fraternal organization like the Elks and the Eagles. My dad was a member of the Elks way back in the day. It seemed like a lot of older folks as well, at least back then.
Fast forward to my dealings, I was quite surprised the number of younger folks that were members of those two organizations.
I know the Eagles bar sure was popular when I was there. Maybe private organizations offer cheaper food and drink options that make them popular with younger folks? My nextdoor neighbor who is in his late 40’s is an Elks member. I just thought it was an interesting dynamic.
SF
 
I'm only a data point of one, but video games came into being when I was a kid. I'm talking pong, which believe it or not, was amazing when it came out. But I think the internet/social media thing is an extension of what the introduction of video games started. I found that my friends no longer wanted to play hoop, baseball, fish or any other outside activity any longer and just wanted to play video games either at the local mini-mart or at home.
I admittedly love videogames. But single player games that take the place of what most people use as TV or movie time. It's the only thing that will get me to sit and just relax for a little bit. Something I only do when I have no other obligations and just need to unwind.

The online multi-player stuff though.. I stay far away from that 😂 very different world.
 
I was lucky enough to have had a colleague at work take me under his wing or at least introduce me to his Buds but saved me getting savaged, too much….Fast forward 20 yrs and I know so much more and am a trusted member of that small, tight group. The bummer is I’m 15-20 yrs behind them and things are slowing down for one of them at least. Wouldn’t change it for the world but trying not to think ahead too far now.

Re Elks, it’s all about location, location, location. Ballard Elks is heaving as a great spot for SUPs, loads of parking, affordable boozing/pretty good bar food with nice folks and Olympic views to rival Ray’s, all for not a lot of dough (~$140 pa). Don’t know the age demographic but likely well under 50. Louis, strongly bucks that trend, an amazing lady.

Dave
 
It's not just the in-person clubs, this forum deals with a similar issue. We have an aging forum user-base with little to no replenishment from the younger generations. I think our youngest usual contributors are mid to late 30s if my estimates are right. Us admins are much younger than our average user, and we're all in our mid 40s.

Younger folks are very much tuned-in to bite-size pieces of info fed to them like a firehose. Their "social" life is through online videogames, TikTok, and other such things. I have a 17yr old and it's been painful to watch as he grows. We've tried, but there's only so much you can do. Thankfully, he's started doing a few in-person activities with some of his friends from school band class.

I don't know that I have solutions, but the problem is absolutely the addictive nature of the online social platforms and the way the internet in general has evolved. Everything is about keeping eyes on the screen and dumping as much at them as possible. Their entire worldview was shaped by this and it's extremely difficult to compete with algorithms specifically designed to hook young people.
Proud to represent the small contingent of regular contributors in their mid 20s 😎
I admittedly love videogames. But single player games that take the place of what most people use as TV or movie time. It's the only thing that will get me to sit and just relax for a little bit. Something I only do when I have no other obligations and just need to unwind.

The online multi-player stuff though.. I stay far away from that
😂
very different world.
It's funny, as I have gotten older it's been the opposite for me. As a kid I loved slow paced single player games but now I rarely play video games except to connect with friends
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zak
I have never joined a ff club. As someone winding down their 40’s and never having had any kids, it’s not like I haven’t had the time. It’s really about interest though. I love fishing. More than anything else I do with my free time hobby wise. I want to spend my free time fishing though. Not participating in fly fishing club related activities or obligations. As far as meeting folks to fish with. PNWFF is a great place to do that. I have no problems fishing solo but of the folks I fish with regularly, a good chunk I interacted with here first (or WFF) mixed in with people I know from my personal life as well as a couple I randomly met out fishing. I did not even put in a lot of effort (or any) to meet those folks. Just kind of happened naturally. As others have already said, the thing clubs might offer I’d be interested in would be sharing the skills I have learned over the years fly fishing and tying (probably more the fishing part of it :)) with folks new to the sport or with other charitable ff organizations. I’d give up time on the water for that but not for meetings, general socializing, etc..
 
This might ruffle some feathers but I consider fly clubs where old men go to socialize.
I tried three different ones near me when I first started and they were a snooze fest. Most of the people there didn’t even fish anymore or if they did it was maybe an eastern Washington lake once a year in the spring and an S River if it was open during the fall.

Maybe there’s some good ones out there but I got the impression it’s where fly fishermen go to die.
going to socialize, and going to die - hmm, two different things.
 
This might ruffle some feathers but I consider fly clubs where old men go to socialize.
I tried three different ones near me when I first started and they were a snooze fest. Most of the people there didn’t even fish anymore or if they did it was maybe an eastern Washington lake once a year in the spring and an S River if it was open during the fall.

Maybe there’s some good ones out there but I got the impression it’s where fly fishermen go to die.
This x 100 is my experience as well when I was younger. Could have been where I was living but the primary focus was on resident trout in lakes in the land of salmon, steelhead and sea-run cutthroat.
 
Guess i am out of touch.

Last video game I played was Pong.

Never had a Facebook account, nor IG, nor X, nor TikTok. I am not missing anything because I never had it.

Given that countries are banning use of social media for teens, some common sense is finally being used.

I luv talking face to face. Being immersed in conversation, seeing facial and hand/body gestures, hearing tonal changes makes it a lot more fun and increases understanding there are real people, life has value, and are worth the effort.

I can remember when telephones were the primary method of communication at work. When email came into being, my number of calls dropped in half. When IMs came into being, my phone almost stopped ringing. Building relationships almost came to stop.

Not sure what AI is going to do but I am concerned.

Mankind is a social being. It is good for physical and mental health. We need to get back to that.

End of rant....
 
Last edited:
My buddy joined the Seattle Elks, Drinking a rainier tall boy on the beach bar at Shilshole on a fine summer evening was pretty damn good, add in a burger and chips, put your ticket in for the wine raffle....
 
I'm sure there are some great clubs. I've met really nice people that were in good clubs so probably would enjoy them.

My first taste of a fly fishing club happened when I was 13 or 14. I've told the story before...short story, 3 or 4 guys from the Portland Fly club. This is back in the early 80s. They were old, rich and stuffy. My buddy and I caught way more fish than they did since we fished weighted nymphs and they only fished dries. And they just didn't seem very happy.
To get a bit darker and deeper...They were literally the sort of men that my dad and grandfather hated and had warned me about. Men you shouldn't trust. I'm sure my view was tainted and at least one of those guys was probably a good dude.

So I just never had an interest until I was in my late 20s. I joined the Sky Valley chapter of TU and was fairly active. We were a new chapter so we all felt like we had a stake in it. Helped with some projects like clipping smolts at Wallace hatchery, fish derbies at Lake Frye, etc.

By my mid-30s I was too busy working 50-60 hrs a week and raising 2 boys. By 40s, it was sports, including coaching jr football and aau basketball. Also involved with our church- men's group, facilities team and youth group volunteer. Lots of mtb and dirt biking during those years too. Definitely no time for a fly club.

I have the time now, but not sure it's my cup of tea. I'd rather spend time with friends, family and fishing.
 
What it boils down to is that people thrive in, and NEED a "third place." A place that is outside of the home and work where the sole purpose is social interaction. For some it's clubs, others it's church, sports, gyms, etc etc.

In addition to my own health, the main driver that's kept me committed to my fitness, both at my gym (which is an extremely social one, not just a gym you show up to and do your own thing. It's all organized classes), or run clubs, etc.... If not for the added social element, I'm not sure I would've stuck with it like I have.

Outside of PNWFF and a couple other online forums, that's my only real social outlet. It's the only IN PERSON one I have. I know a LOT of people who ONLY have work and home, and they can't quite figure out why they feel like they're missing something in their lives. Even introverts like myself need time socializing with others. It's just how we're wired.
 
Back
Top