How Many Knots Are In Your Arsenal?

Wade Rivers said:
I'll add a second vote for the Perfection Loop. Quick and easy and sticks straight at the end of the line...not askew like the surgeon's.

Did I miss it? Nobody mentioned the Davey knot. A couple of my buddies are big fans of the Davey
Click to expand...

Some really like the Davey , I learned it years ago ,very simple ,not sure I remember it now . It is a quick one , but the improved clinch was the first fishing knot my brother showed me ,and just found it good enough to tie on flies .
 
I am kind of amazed at all the love for clinch and improved clinch knots. The clinch is at least pretty easy to tie, but the pitzen (or 16-20) is easier than an improved clinch, and significantly stronger, as are a bunch of other knots. I guess it’s the first one most people learn and it’s good enough most of the time - until its not and you get that little curly tail on the end of your tippet and the lost big fish.

Uni knot should get more love than it does for joining lines, but most people hate it - because most of the directions in books or on the internet show a bad way of doing it that makes it seat wrong half the time.
 
Fishing knots based on frequency of use: Turle (Holbrook version), blood or barrel knot, Improved clinch knot, Perfection Loop, double overhand, double surgeon, and of course, wind knots.
 
I've used many already mentioned but have found the Uni-Knot to be extremely versatile. Simple to tie and strong. Main uses are uni-to-uni connections, for leaders and leader to mainline. Especially when connecting different line types. The exception for leader to mainline would be reel on leaders for tuna jigging. I use the FG knot for that instead, but gotta look into the Crazy Alberto if it's easier.

Also use a uni for fly connections where strength is critical (tuna), or heavy water salmon. Loop it through the hook eye and tie onto the leader. Makes a very strong open loop knot for fly fishing, with the downside it cinches down after landing a fish (should re-tie anyway after landing a tuna).

For other conventional fishing a uni works great to attach a dropper tag for weight. Two advantages with this being it does not "interrupt" the integrity of the line it's tied to. And, if tied properly, it applies enough friction to hold in place during casting and fishing, but loose enough to manually slide the dropper tag so the effective length of the leader can be adjusted based on conditions.

I still use the perfection loop for flies in most freshwater applications, but that with the Uni covers 90% of my knot needs.
 
Years of gillnetting, longlining and mountaineering have given me a vast arsenal of knots from which to draw, but the sportfish-specific knots I use most are -
Non-slip loop (Lefty's)
Clinch, Improved Clinch
Blood
Uni (mostly as a Snell knot when beading)
Slim Beauty - perfect for hard-butt nymphing leaders and warm water bite tippet alike
San Diego Jam
Bimini - the only knot I've used for spraypole running lines for decades now
Palomar - the best spectra-to-swivel knot there is

I'd also like to take this moment to remind folks that despite its name, the Perfection loop is the shittiest knot ever invented, and is a fool's knot in anything less than 25#.
 
Chucker said:
I am kind of amazed at all the love for clinch and improved clinch knots. The clinch is at least pretty easy to tie, but the pitzen (or 16-20) is easier than an improved clinch, and significantly stronger, as are a bunch of other knots. I guess it’s the first one most people learn and it’s good enough most of the time - until its not and you get that little curly tail on the end of your tippet and the lost big fish.

Uni knot should get more love than it does for joining lines, but most people hate it - because most of the directions in books or on the internet show a bad way of doing it that makes it seat wrong half the time.
Click to expand...

I don't know how many big trout I have landed with 4X , and a improved clinch knot, I don't use the clinch . Have I been broke off ,yes ,but it's been more operator error, than a knot . In all my years of fly fishing the improved clinch knot has never convinced me I need a better knot , just my opinion . Not the first time I have heard this about the clinch ,and improved clinch . I have to wonder if people really know how to tie one correctly ?

Here again ,the surgeons knot is about all I use to tie tippet or tags , or just lines together unless I use a tippet ring , and that is a different discussion . :) These knots to me are simple to tie , they have always worked well for me . Uni knot ,never had the desire nor needed , IMO keep it simple .
 
up2nogood said:
I don't know how many big trout I have landed with 4X , and a improved clinch knot, I don't use the clinch . Have I been broke off ,yes ,but it's been more operator error, than a knot . In all my years of fly fishing the improved clinch knot has never convinced me I need a better knot , just my opinion . Not the first time I have heard this about the clinch ,and improved clinch . I have to wonder if people really know how to tie one correctly ?

Here again ,the surgeons knot is about all I use to tie tippet or tags , or just lines together unless I use a tippet ring , and that is a different discussion . :) These knots to me are simple to tie , they have always worked well for me . Uni knot ,never had the desire nor needed , IMO keep it simple .
Click to expand...
Indeed!

In the 65 years I've used the improved clinch knot it's never failed me...and that includes hard fighting heavy river redbands at nearly 30" length.

Over the years I fooled around with various loop knots like the Orvis knot to improve fly movement but frankly I found they made no discernible improvement in catch rate..in fact far less compared to tippet diameter and material.

So...for my trout fishing the improved clinch and the nail knot are all I need...since I long ago started using tippet rings...tied with the same clinch knot of course!

Any knot will fail if it's poorly tied or not periodically inspected for wear and tear.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top