Do chironomids on a straight shank hook even work at all, bro?
When I first started fly fishing I don't think very many people were tying on anything but straight shank hooks (keep in mind, given my senior (Boomer) citizen status that Mustad was almost the only game in town). Then one day along came Tiemco and the 2457. I tied chironomids on 2457's, by the fly box full. Anymore, I rarely tie on that hook. Why? Easy - so many choices, so many options. Like
@Billy, I even tie a few on jig hooks.
A half dozen years ago Herb, Keith and I were up at Mile High Resort, there were two Americans staying in the cabin adjacent to ours. Herb is a great one to chat up people. One evening he came back after chatting up these two guys, his eyes were glassed over (no, not drugs): he'd got bitten by Fish Lore. GIANT trout in a super secret hike in lake. There was no internet access (or cell service at MHR back then) so our research was asking the owners of the resort about this lake. They said "oh, it's over by Lac Le Jeune". We decided to try and find it and eventually did (the next year); The "Ethyl Lake" chromie on my favorite chironomid hook:
I sure wish I'd seen the trout that ate one of these -----^ It took off and nearly spooled me. I couldn't slow it down.
For what its worth, the lake ain't super secret anymore and given that Lac Le Jeune has become yuppie SUP paradise, many locals have migrated to and somehow managed to get old boats into Ethyl and leave them chained to trees. The once remote lake is now pressured.