Commander SUP? Why not?

skyriver

Legend
Forum Supporter
It's been well established that stand-up paddle boards and/or kayaks are pretty darn good weapons in the carp game. Especially when solo on small water with a soft bottom.
Do I want one more inflatable? No...a raft, a Commander and a float tube take up enough room in my garage. Not to mention a 17' boat.

So...why not mod the 10' by almost 4" Commander that I already have into a SUP? Well, there are probably several reasons. Some of which I already know and others that I'm sure I'll find out.

But hey, let's send it and see! So off to Home Depot I went.

I started with a 4x8 sheet of 7/16 OSB. I cut a 2'x4' section off the end and then shaped and sanded it to fit from the back zipper to the end of the foot peg tubes. Then covered it with indoor/outdoor carpet. I still have plenty of carpet left to give my side bunks new life. And a 4x6 piece of OSB for future projects like some shelving in the dirt-bag chalet. The OSB, carpet, 77 adhesive and some wall pipe clamps totaled $60. Not bad given all the leftovers I have.

Onto the chair. My old duck hunting chair was the perfect candidate! It has a straight up posture and makes for easy standing. And the base is just wide enough to feel quite stable. It also has an insulated zippered pocket underneath. Still some dried duck & dove blood in there. Haha!

The chair is zip tied to the OSB using 2 holes drilled on each side of the leg/frame. Super high tech. 😁 Very solid though!

The only thing keeping the OSB in place is gravity and air pressure. It's squeezed in there tight between the tubes enough that standing on the front lip or the sides didn't pop it out. I did this test in the lake in 2' of water with nobody else there. Haha!
I would feel comfortable in a seated position even in some chop. No problem. Now, if I get sideways right when a wake board from hell goes by then it's probably swimming time. But in a non-power lake I feel completely confident I can stay dry. And casting a long line on my 5wt was no issue sitting.

About standing...I was pleasantly surprised! As mentioned, standing on the front lip or sides was no problem. Standing where my feet are when seated is very stable. I can also stand perpendicular/surf style. I also stepped around and over the chair to the back lip and it was fine. Casting a long line on my 5wt was no problem standing.

What about the tracking? Yeah, not great, but better than expected! I used one of the Commander oars as a paddle since I don't own any paddles and it's actually a great length. I have a good idea of what size paddle I'll need now. Paddling while sitting is pretty easy and once I have some speed I can paddle and control my line by paddling and steering on just one side.
Now that it passed the first test, I'll add a fin/skeg using these cheap parts from Sea Eagle-
https://www.seaeagle.com/Accessories/parts/skeg-base-for-all-skegs
$15
https://www.seaeagle.com/Accessorie...g-for-sups-fasttracks-explorers-and-razorlite
$29
This should help the tracking when under power. Speaking of power...ah yeah...I think I could easily add a trolling motor. Haha! We'll see how much I use it before doing that.

I'll definitely make a stakeout/anchor pole from Home Depot. Lots of videos out there on how to do that for under $30. I can either use the natural gap between the seat/middle section and the back of the tubes or mount something off one of the IGS pads. The left pad might make sense being a right-hander.

I've seen guys just add a stainless ring to a Scotty mount that is on their IGS pad of their kayak. Should be pretty easy to come up with something.

So whether you have the old model like me or the new one, it's pretty easy to make it a standup fishing weapon.

Hmm, this might work
20250829_165620.jpg

Here goes nothing!
20250830_140101.jpg

No flippy!
20250830_135903.jpg

Took a selfie and still didn't fall in!
20250830_134213.jpg

And this has to be a good sign!
20250830_134135.jpg

If any of you have a paddle in the 5-6' range you like let me know!

Now I need a carp fighting test!
 
great job..might consider replacing what looks like standard zip ties? with beefy 120# zip ties.
Regarding paddles, SUP paddles are generally sized 8 to 10 inches over one's height, and because of the width of yours might consider adding a few inches to that. An inexpensive adjustable paddle should work fine for your needs, checkout Seachoice 71171
 
great job..might consider replacing what looks like standard zip ties? with beefy 120# zip ties.
Regarding paddles, SUP paddles are generally sized 8 to 10 inches over one's height, and because of the width of yours might consider adding a few inches to that. An inexpensive adjustable paddle should work fine for your needs, checkout Seachoice 71171
Yeah, I agree. And I have some...somewhere in my garage. Haha! Yeah, it's a mess out there right now. Constant battle.
 
Very clever! I can see where a motor might be a nice addition if you want to go distance to that magic carp flat.
 
Just an update.
I went out bassin last night in this thing since my new paddle had arrived. Fishing was secondary to figuring out this contraption. I'm calling her CommandUP. 😁
First thing I noticed, since it was a bit windy when I arrived...it needs a skeg/fin! I've ordered one and will install.
Second thing, I have the seat too far forward. I'll move it back half the distance to the back of the platform. This, combined with the skeg/fin will help the tracking. It's not great without those things. It's not terribly slow, but keeping things straight was a challenge.
Third, since I'll be moving the seat back I need to secure the front of the platform to the foot pegs. This will prevent the platform from creeping or rubbing on the tubes.

I probably won't be using CommandUP for bass or trout fishing. Regular mode with fins on my feet is just way more effective for fishing. It was nice being up higher for vision, especially to see just how big (or small) the buckets in the lily pads are. But there is too much fidgeting with the paddle to position.
In the places that were shallow enough to stake out it worked very well. So I'm still stoked about it's carp potential.

Both the seated and standing position will be good for carp. Way less glare and better visibility. You don't have to be able to see your fly when carpin, but you do have to see the fish.

Maybe CommadURP? CommandSUP? CommandSUK? :ROFLMAO:
 
Maybe CommadURP? CommandSUP? CommandSUK? :ROFLMAO:
Not CommandSUP.;) I admire your ingenuity to customize and try something different with a craft you already own. As you've found out many of the design characteristics of the Commander make it difficult to use as a SUP. Don't misconstrue my reaction to the project as being negative towards the idea. Inflatable SUPs make excellent fishing craft and are my favorite way to fish freshwater.
 
Not CommandSUP.;) I admire your ingenuity to customize and try something different with a craft you already own. As you've found out many of the design characteristics of the Commander make it difficult to use as a SUP. Don't misconstrue my reaction to the project as being negative towards the idea. Inflatable SUPs make excellent fishing craft and are my favorite way to fish freshwater.
I'm trying to figure out how this SUP fishing thing works. -Not that I'm in the market, but curious. The way I see it you'd be standing up and so pushed whichever way the wind chooses, unless you're actively paddling. Doing that requires two hands on the paddle. How does that work with fishing, especially fly fishing?
I suppose I could youtube up an answer, but I'm old, and would rather read than watch some gopro jockey blather on.
Thanks.
 
Sort of a DIY version of the Wilderness Systems iATAK:


1757102816243.png
 
@Snopro not taken negatively at all. It's definitely not perfect. And virtually ALL SUPs out there would beat it in a race. I have a couple small lakes and ponds in mind where I could use this fairly effectively for carp. Maybe that's it?! Carp Commander! 😁

@Phil K in the time it took you to type that you could've watched a cool video about fishing from a SUP like this guy-


@Josh key words "sort of" :ROFLMAO:
 
well, if you DO decide to fish it in SUP form for trout or bass, just get yourself a drift sock and set up your drift. a buddy of mine fishes for tigers off of his actual SUP and when he's not actively trolling, that's often how he's doing it. It definitely takes a little more thought into how you approach things, but it still seems to work great.
 
The way I see it you'd be standing up and so pushed whichever way the wind chooses, unless you're actively paddling. Doing that requires two hands on the paddle. How does that work with fishing, especially fly fishing?
There are many ways of dealing with wind on a SUP depending on variables. Things like...wind strength, species you're after, body of water, type of gear, etc. Generally I only use the SUP in lighter winds. When it picks up I switch to the Hobie.

In no particular order...

Anchor
Stake out pole
Vegetation clip
Wind drift
Troll
Ground the Nose
Drift sock
Flippers
 
Back
Top