NFR Riding lawnmower discovery

iveofione

Legend
Forum Supporter
I have been using a 42'' Craftsman riding mower that I bought new in 2004. It has led a hell of a difficult life as I use it for a field mower more than a lawnmower. It has been very dependable, starts instantly and runs smooth. It has had but one oil change and filter in 20 years. Many of you probably have a similar mower as they were built primarily by one company but with at least 5 different brand names. It is a solid but not brilliant design that lasts long and the deck can easily and reasonably be rebuilt to extend the life. I bought mine for around $650, the same mower is around $2200 nowadays so rebuilding the deck for under $200 makes a lot of sense.

A couple of days ago mowing just before dark I hit a root that stopped the mower in an instant and blew the top bearing off of one of the spindles. It did other damage too trashing the 2 main pulleys and twisting a blade. The spindles are the heart of the operation and bearing failure is a common problem. They aren't real expensive but are a real pain in the ass to replace because you have to remove the deck in order to replace them.

So today I pulled it apart and surveyed the damage. One of the spindles is still in excellent shape and since I have ordered all new parts I took the remaining spindle apart just to see how it was made. And here is where it gets interesting. The existing spindles have a zerk fitting on top ostensibly to pump grease into the top and bottom bearings. But the bearings are both sealed! An entire cartridge of grease could be pumped into the spindle and not a single molecule of it would ever reach a bearing surface!! How anything so stupid could actually make it into production is mind boggling.

When the new ones arrive I will drill and tap them for a zerk fitting, drill a tiny weep hole at the top and fill them with boat trailer grease. A seal will be removed from each bearing of course and no further maintenance should be required other than the occasional pump of a grease gun. They make these things by the thousands since every mower needs at least 2 of them, it is hard to image how such an engineering gaffe can survive for so many years. I wonder if they are all like that or just one factory dummied up and has been building them wrong for years.
 
I have been using a 42'' Craftsman riding mower that I bought new in 2004. It has led a hell of a difficult life as I use it for a field mower more than a lawnmower. It has been very dependable, starts instantly and runs smooth. It has had but one oil change and filter in 20 years. Many of you probably have a similar mower as they were built primarily by one company but with at least 5 different brand names. It is a solid but not brilliant design that lasts long and the deck can easily and reasonably be rebuilt to extend the life. I bought mine for around $650, the same mower is around $2200 nowadays so rebuilding the deck for under $200 makes a lot of sense.

A couple of days ago mowing just before dark I hit a root that stopped the mower in an instant and blew the top bearing off of one of the spindles. It did other damage too trashing the 2 main pulleys and twisting a blade. The spindles are the heart of the operation and bearing failure is a common problem. They aren't real expensive but are a real pain in the ass to replace because you have to remove the deck in order to replace them.

So today I pulled it apart and surveyed the damage. One of the spindles is still in excellent shape and since I have ordered all new parts I took the remaining spindle apart just to see how it was made. And here is where it gets interesting. The existing spindles have a zerk fitting on top ostensibly to pump grease into the top and bottom bearings. But the bearings are both sealed! An entire cartridge of grease could be pumped into the spindle and not a single molecule of it would ever reach a bearing surface!! How anything so stupid could actually make it into production is mind boggling.

When the new ones arrive I will drill and tap them for a zerk fitting, drill a tiny weep hole at the top and fill them with boat trailer grease. A seal will be removed from each bearing of course and no further maintenance should be required other than the occasional pump of a grease gun. They make these things by the thousands since every mower needs at least 2 of them, it is hard to image how such an engineering gaffe can survive for so many years. I wonder if they are all like that or just one factory dummied up and has been building them wrong for years.

The sealed bearings were probably cheaper than the unsealed bearings plus the grease. Economics overrules engineering...
 
Never use a riding mower on a slope. A best friend died that way. Didn’t get hit with the blade, mower tipped over, landed on him and snapped his neck.
Sorry for the downer.
 
You mean like the Ford Pinto and Chevrolet Vega?

Yeah, kinda like that.

I am a Ford Pinto (Mercury Bobcat, actually) survivor. It was my first car, and I did get rear-ended once. Lots of cut corners, but not really a bad car for its day. Ford management sucked, though.
 
Yeah, kinda like that.

I am a Ford Pinto (Mercury Bobcat, actually) survivor. It was my first car, and I did get rear-ended once. Lots of cut corners, but not really a bad car for its day. Ford management sucked, though.
Back in grade school in the 1980s, before any of us in the cohort really knew anything about cars, it was considered a serious insult to claim that someone “drove a Pinto.” Now I’d be more likely to be the weirdo who fixes one up super factory-clean and takes it to car shows.
 
I'm glad to hear you can fix it, fantastic. I hit a big rock in back and bent up the blade on my 30yr old craftsman push mower this spring. Everyone goes "now you can buy an electric one". Ha, for $9.98 it's as good as it ever was, for the third time.
 
Gotta a Honda push mower working on 34 years old . Bought in 1991 . Original bag , held together with zip ties . I have replaced a cable , blade ,and I think the wheels twice . It's never failed to start on the first pull . I keep thinking this is it's last year ,but just keeps on running .
 
Many of you probably have a similar mower as they were built primarily by one company but with at least 5 different brand names.

An entire cartridge of grease could be pumped into the spindle and not a single molecule of it would ever reach a bearing surface!! How anything so stupid could actually make it into production is mind boggling.
Boeing?
 
Back in grade school in the 1980s, before any of us in the cohort really knew anything about cars, it was considered a serious insult to claim that someone “drove a Pinto.” Now I’d be more likely to be the weirdo who fixes one up super factory-clean and takes it to car shows.


I remember when driving a Hyundai was only for the poor and downtrodden. Now I can't afford one.

My how times have changed.
 
I remember when driving a Hyundai was only for the poor and downtrodden. Now I can't afford one.

My how times have changed.

So true!!

On the mower tip—

The electric mowers are nice. I have a 30-minute mow yard. Small but lots of little things to mow around. When we moved in I got on Craigslist and found a push mower for $20; when I got there it was free. I half assed sharpened the blade and added oil and fuel and knocked the dirt out of the air filter. It was working when my wife bought me a Ryobi electric mower. So. Much. Better. I don’t have to buy fuel or add oil=time and money savings. It’s much lighter and quieter and doesn’t make smelly exhaust. It has fewer moving parts. I put the old ICE one on OfferUp and it was gone the same day. It’s excellent to make the most of what one has, but I also think it’s okay to upgrade/update when the technology has advanced so much and offers numerous advantages—monetarily, effort-wise, health-wise, etc.
 
I have an eGo electric mower that I use around the house and it is a real game changer. In the spring just drop the battery in, push a button and the blade starts, close a lever and it starts moving forward with a throttle close at hand. None of the usual spring time arm wrestling with a pull cord, choke, fresh gas or filters. It runs a long time too, I did my yard yesterday for the 2nd time on a charge and still had 25% left. Easy and quiet and if your wife mows the yard be a good husband and buy her one. It is too nice to take "off road" like I do the riding mower and for the really tough stuff I have a 5' brush hog on my tractor that makes short work of tall grass.

I have ordered new parts to rebuild the deck on the riding mower and if they actually fit I will have the equivalent of a new mower for $110. I'm suspicious though, Amazon has a warning that: "These parts are frequently returned."
 
I like how Ive is fixing up this mower so that it will probably outlast him by several decades. (Not that we don't wish him many more happy years.)

Do it right, or don't do it at all.
 
That and a set of these is what I grew up with.
View attachment 117929
Little did I know that early on I was doing my part to save the planet.:)
We had a huge terraced double lot...and my job as an only child) was to mow and keep all of the brick terrace walls where they abutted the lawn neatly manicured with those damn shears. I would have killed for a 'weed whipper'...something that was invented about 40 years later.

I hated the whole business of lawncare (though taking care of neighborhood lawns did provide some childhood income).

On our own big lawn I thought, (in my 10 year old mind) that I might possibly avoid the whole ordeal if I 'accidently' sheared off a few sprinkler heads with our Craftsman mower. I knew just the right candidates for a reasonably plausible accident.

Didn't work...the old man just added sprinkler repair to my repertoire of landscaping duties.
 
Back
Top