Seeking advice on Bahamas+bonefish+beaches

[Doublebluff]

My wife agreed to such a trip. It can't be a fishing trip disguised as a beach vacation. Quiet beach fun is more important. But, one guided day for me plus some DIY effort... that can happen. A single bonefish on a fly is the bar I will set, everything else is gravy. Any ideas would be appreciated.

 

[chief]

Cape Santa Maria on Long Island could be a good option for what you are looking for. Or Chez Pierre, also on Long Island, if you don't mind more spartan accommodations.

 

[Stonedfish]

I did a guide day with Garth Thompson on Exuma. He got us into a lot of bones.
He was super laid back and didn’t talk much other then to continually pointing out bonefish.
SF

 

[Greg Armstrong]

Eleuthera has everything you mentioned.
DIY or guided, lots of secluded beaches and flats, quaint villages.