More on reels...

iveofione

Legend
Forum Supporter
I see the world a little differently than most of my peers and as a result tend to do things my own way rather than in lockstep with conventional wisdom. And reel purchase has been no exception. Rather than buy a variety of fancy name brand reels that are a delight to look at and fish with I opted for affordable standardization without the bling or expense. I wanted everything to be the same and interchange without having to mix and match rods and reels and not have the line selection be limited by a reel that had no spare spool. I wanted affordable reels with readily available spools, they didn't have to be world class, just good dependable reels.

After 3 attempts to buy reels that I could build a system around I was discouraged that manufacturers would drop entire lines of reels or sell the reel but offer no spare spools. I sold or gave away all of those first attempts at standardization. My fishing is pretty much the same year to year, even more so now in my late eighties, and only occasionally do I land a fish in the 5 or 6 pound range. Eventually I landed on the Okuma SLV 5/6b that checked all the boxes for the system I wanted. They are not fancy reels, not pretty, die cast rather than machined and a bit heavier than a CNC reel of comparable size. But I am a grown boy and not one to whimper about an extra couple of ounces of weight. What I got was fairly rugged and dependable reels and so far no one has tried to humiliate me for going cheap. And I did go cheap! In December of 2022 I was shopping for spare spools and found the entire reels were on sale for $34! So instead of buying spools I ordered 6 of the SLV's for a grand total of $204 before tax. They have been outstanding so far with decent drags that have handled fish in the four to six pound range with no problems at all. Today I found spare spools on sale for $25 and ordered 2 more to round out the system with 8 lines for my 5-6 weight stuff, mostly for lake fishing.

The other system I have is for my 3-4-5 weight rods and is 3 lightweight Orvis reels with a total of 9 spools giving me lots of line choices for both stream and lake. For around $700 total I have 9 reel bodies and 17 spools to choose from on any given day. The cost of the fly lines far outweighs the cost of the hardware. On July 28 I will celebrate my first fish caught on a fly rod in 1951 and in 74 years of fly fishing I have learned that time on the water is the best weapon in your quiver. No amount of equipment can make up for lack of savvy.











v
 
I use the Okuma SLV 7-8 reels for salt water in the theory that when they corrode replacement will be cheap. But they haven't corroded yet.
 
When it comes to the 5/6 size which I use most frequently for SRC, coho, and more recently stripers, I'm a fan of the Lamson Liquid 3-packs. I think I have three of them. No failures yet with 90% salt use.

7/8 I've got three Redington Rise w/ a couple extra spools. These are nicer reels than the Lamsons but still pretty affordable esp. since they were all on sale.

Redundancy and standardization are very nice. I'd love to be able to afford a fleet of Makos but I think one of those costs more than my entire fly fishing quiver.
 
My first quality reel was a Lamson LP-2. I have had LP-1.5's and LP-3's also. For the type of fishing I do, LP-2's are on the mark. I have 3 LP-2 reels and 9 LP-2 spools. 30+ years later, still using my original purchase. I have never had any issues with them. Just added more I when I find a good deal.
 
I'll put a few (too many) words in for Galvan reels, which aren't cheap but aren't absurd either.

I'm no professional fly fisher; I've never worked in the industry. Nor am I wealthy or flush with free time. My experience with gear is thus limited so what I'll say here isn't meant to claim expertise. I'm neither an expert angler nor an expert on gear. I fish only for trout and the vast majority of that fishing occurs in freestone rivers that I walk and wade. In fact, I've never even been on drift boat.

Having said all that, I want to say a word for the Galvan OB. I bought mine in roughly 2005 after losing my prior rig (an Orvis Trident and Bauer LM if I remember correctly) in a Rock Creek runoff fall that got pretty close to ending my fishing career, as well as all of my other careers. The old guy at Rock Creek Mercantile said "You're lucky to be alive" after I told him the story on the way out. Don't forget those wading belts, folks!

Anyway, I have used my OB on every fishing trip I have taken for 20 years. Walking and wading freestones is hard on gear—there's a reason the word "stone" is in there. My super rough estimate is that I've caught and released something like 600 trout with that reel, probably a lot more. I've dropped it on rocks, almost lost it in the river, put the rod butt down in sand (on accident), had it fall off of car windshields on the road, submerged it fully nearly every trip, and basically done every careless thing you can do to a reel in these circumstances. I have never cleaned the reel (go ahead and judge), and I've maybe lubed it twice. I'm not a good gear care guy—there's no wiping down and careful pampering of the equipment. It just goes in the reel bag at the end of the trip and comes out at the beginning of the next.

The reel has performed flawlessly. It's never seemed heavy (until I changed rods last year). It's got scratches and dings in the coating but overall I could use it heavily for the next 30+ years and I suspect it would function perfectly every. single. time. even treated the way its been treated over the past two decades. The drag system is great and sealed enough that it's never had sand or dirt inside. The drag is as smooth as it was the day I bought it. The push button spool release is brilliant and as foolproof as it gets. The damn thing is tank and I have never had to service or even think about it in 20+ years.

I just bought a Danielsson to balance the very light new rod I have a little better. But I'm not putting my OB away. Instead it's getting moved to a 2wt nymphing rod where it will no doubt also be flawless. So far, I don't love the Danielsson which seems well made but fiddly and over-engineered.

In the past year or so I've had direct and indirect experiences with other reels in the same class (4/5wt freshwater). My buddy's Hydros has broken twice now. The Evo LTX I bought before the Danielsson seemed far too delicate for the kind of use I expect to give it. I'm sure it's a fine reel, and it's really light, but it felt like one good drop would bend the metal of the cage, drag knob, and/or spool. I sold it. I have an old Remix I bought as a backup and while the price point isn't the same, it's a toy compared to the OB.

Galvan doesn't get the sexy coverage of Hatch or even Ross. I'll also say that I've not used the Rush Light or Torque or Brookie, so I can't personally vouch for those reels. But if you're looking for an American-made, bombproof freestone reel with a great warranty that can easily last over two decades with no service and that you may never have to think about again, consider a Galvan. The fact that they aren't reworking their lineup every two years may mess up the publicity cycle, but to my mind it's a good sign that what they're offering doesn't need to be changed.
 
I have two Galvan torques. I have used one in the salt now for 15 years. Not a single issue. Also what other reel mfger has kept the same design for 21 years. I believe the torque came out in 2004.
 
Eventually I landed on the Okuma SLV 5/6b that checked all the boxes for the system I wanted. They are not fancy reels, not pretty, die cast rather than machined and a bit heavier than a CNC reel of comparable size. But I am a grown boy and not one to whimper about an extra couple of ounces of weight. What I got was fairly rugged and dependable reels and so far no one has tried to humiliate me for going cheap. And I did go cheap! In December of 2022 I was shopping for spare spools and found the entire reels were on sale for $34!
I like this thread because you make a great point, that high end equipment is not needed to enjoy the sport. Having said that I actually did not really enjoy the Okuma reel you mention, no good reason really, it just didn't feel right to me though most of my reels are still in the budget category from Redington, Lamson, and Orvis. For that reason I have that exact reel for sale on the 'old' forum site if anyone is interested. Oddly the clicker fell off at some point so while it is silent it still functions just fine. It's been up a few days with no takers so I'd be willing to match your sale price of $34 for anyone on this site. Cheers.

 
Back
Top