Montana Brown Trout

Stonedfish

Known Pluviophile
Forum Supporter
A buddy sent this to me today.
Anyone fishing over there this year catch any of those sick looking browns?
SF

 
Pretty bad when the fish that made it through whirling D are now being affected as well! Do you think OMJ saw this coming?
 
I am lucky enough to have access to a lot of SW Montana water via retired living in Bozeman. I get on the water a lot from March to November. So far this year angling on five different rivers in multiple locations, I’ve yet to encounter any diseased brown, rainbows, cutts or whitefish. 100s of fish so far this season, not one that I recall was “sick”. In fact even in the last few weeks, as river temps have been rising, fish are still fat and healthy. One of the problems in my view with the reporting is the lack of context. The headline and text give the impression that the entire Big Hole and Beaverhead rivers are suffering from diseased fish. Indeed MTFWP surveys have documented population declines in the surveyed sections, but these are big rivers. The Big Hole at 153 miles long, probably less than 50% of that length gets the most fishing pressure. There are remote sections that get almost zero pressure because of access and have healthy populations of fish. Of course outfitters and local anglers sweat these kinds of problems and the media gladly soaks up that sweat in its reporting. August will be a tough angling month due to low water and high temps but thats pretty much normal. Hoot Owls and a shorter season on the Big Hole will help the browns recover and I suspect the studies being undertaken to diagnose the “sick trout” will help as well.
 
This past June the Big Hole treated me better than the Madison. I was a bit perplexed at the reports of the decline in numbers on the Big Hole. You couldn't have proved it by me.
 
Eh, they're just invasives....that prey on natives.
 
A significant increase in angling pressure, grip and grin pics all over the Internet, and the cyclical nature of salmonid populations, so let's all freak out now. Honestly there are places and certain sections of rivers that fish way better now than they did when I lived in SW Montana in the 80s and 90s. There are also places and sections of rivers that get the piss pounded out of them year round that don't fish as well. Irrigation drawdowns and warm water have always been an issue, there is just an increase in awareness as of late. It wasn't that uncommon in my time there to have good fishing before lunch, and good swimming after lunch for most of the summer.
 
Back
Top