Drama with the Traver, Local Duda wins it ....

Wadin' Boot

Badly tied flies, mediocre content
Forum Supporter
Congratulations to Steve, cool guy, fierce promotor of the outdoors!

Here's the press release and a link to Steve's story

2026 Robert Traver Fly-Fishing Writing Award
New Winner Announced

The John D. Voelker Foundation and the American Museum of Fly Fishing (AMFF) are
pleased to announce a new winner of the 2026 Robert Traver Fly-Fishing Writing Award: “The
Goddess of Compassion, Holding Open the Door” by Steve Duda of Seattle, Washington.


The previously announced winner was disqualified due to violation of our policy prohibiting
AI-generated writing. We congratulate our most deserving winner and deeply regret the
circumstances that led to the disqualification.

“The Goddess of Compassion, Holding Open the Door” is a refreshing personal contemplation
on river rocks collected while fly fishing, told with humor, curiosity and quiet lyricism.
According to our judges, it embodies the Traver Award criteria by celebrating the joy of fly
fishing, the personal and philosophical experience, humor, and appreciation of the environs
where trout are found.
“For me, fly fishing has always been a way into stories about places, people, history and the
things we only notice when we’re out there—the stuff that helps us understand the world and,
maybe, become a little more human in it,” Duda said. “To have this work recognized by the
Traver Award means a great deal to me.”
The winning entry earns a $2,500 prize and is available to read on the American Museum of
Fly Fishing’s website at amff.org/traver-winners-2026/ and the Voelker Foundation website at
www.voelkerfoundation.com. The story will also be published in the Winter 2027 issue of the
American Fly Fisher, the journal of the American Museum of Fly Fishing.

Steve Duda is the former editor of The Flyfish Journal and author of River Songs: Moments of
Wild Wonder in Fly Fishing, winner of a Silver Independent Publisher Book Award and a
finalist for the Washington State Book Award, Foreword INDIES Book of the Year Awards and
Banff Mountain Book Competition. His next book, We Only Arrive, will be published by
Mountaineers Books in fall 2027. His writing has appeared in Rolling Stone, The Fretboard
Journal, Seattle Weekly, San Francisco Bay Guardian and other publications. A founding editor of
Boise Weekly, Duda is currently Head of Fish Tales at Patagonia and lives in Seattle.

The Traver Award judges also bestowed Honorable Mention recognition on “The Big Bang
Theory” by Tim Schulz of Houghton, Michigan which is available on the American Museum
of Fly Fishing and Voelker Foundation websites. Honorable mention writers receive a $250
prize.
The 2026 competition drew a field of 77 stories and essays. Entries were judged anonymously,
resulting in seven finalists. The other four finalists were:
“Falling Scales” by Genevieve Bentz, Bethesda, MD
“Hands and Fish” by Henry Hughes, Monmouth, OR
“Hatches of the Mind” by David Lynch, Concord, MA
“The Gorge” by Norm Richter, Lexington, MA
The Traver Award is named after Robert Traver, pen name of the late John D. Voelker, author
of Trout Madness, Trout Magic, Anatomy of a Fisherman, the 1958 best seller Anatomy of a Murder,
and the fine historical novel Laughing Whitefish. Judge Voelker also served on the Michigan
Supreme Court as its 74th justice from 1956 to 1960. A collection of Voelker’s finest “yarns”
and observations about fishing was published posthumously by Nick Lyons in 2001 under the
title Traver on Fishing.
A new anthology of Traver Award stories from 2008 through 2025 titled Trout Do Not Lie will
be released November 3, 2026 by Stackpole Books/Globe Pequot. Two earlier anthologies of
Traver Award winners, finalists, and other stories have been published: In Hemingway’s
Meadow (2009) and Love Story of the Trout (2010).
The Traver Award was created in 1994 to encourage and recognize “distinguished original
stories or essays that embody the implicit love of fly-fishing, respect for the sport, and the
natural world in which it takes place.” The winning story or essay must demonstrate high
literary values in one or more of these three categories:
—The joy of fly-fishing: personal and philosophic experience
—Ecology: knowledge and protection of the natural world
—Humor: piscatorial friendships and fun on the water
The Voelker Foundation and the American Museum of Fly Fishing joined forces in 2018 to
administer the Traver Award and publish the winner in the AMFF journal. For more
information, see www.voelkerfoundation.com and www.amff.org.
 
I went into this thinking it was a thread about Jim Travers.
Travers could still be the guy who submitted the AI entry that initially won it, so we may not know for sure... They ran the entries through multiple AI based checkers for AI signatures, and all of them flagged the winning entry and the original winner could not back up the entry with cogent drafts or revisions that had no AI signatures...

Duda would presumably listen to shitty 80's hair metal than ever use AI.
 
I'm pretty sure Travers' literary efforts have never been of AI origin....or even the product of general organic human intelligence....although Super Intelligence can't be entirely ruled out.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top