Arid Cataract Lake, March 2022

Cabezon

Sculpin Enterprises
Forum Supporter
Day 1 of 3. When the arrow-leaved balsamroot blooms,
A01ArrowleavedBalsamrootP4010151.jpg

it is time to visit “Arid Cataract Lake” with @Cowlitz Bottomfeeder for a few days.

As we descended toward the lake, I could see that the open shallows at the south end, which had been prime trout habitat when I first fished this lake 20+ years ago, were even more chocked by invasive Phragmites reeds and cattails. There were already three or four rigs in the parking area, but that is a light day for this lake in the spring. Not atypically, the day started with gusty winds in the teens, but fortunately the winds dropped through the afternoon. High temps were in the 60’s. I was soon on the water and soaking in the scenery.
A02NorthWallP3290007.jpg

I started out watching a bobber that was floating a brace of chironomid flies for the first few hours. There was a solid chironomid emergence but the fishing started slow early in the day. So, I was mostly soaking in the sounds of this amazing lake. Several pairs of Canada geese on the grass-covered peninsula nearby noisily squabbled and honked. The songs of male red-winged blackbirds rang out from the dried, brown reeds at the water’s edge. Small groups of coots dove at the edges of the lake and made their squeeky calls. A few times I heard a series of strange bleating whoops, the song of a pied-billed grebe; for such a small bird, they make a big sound. The distinctive, high-pitched cry of peregrine falcons reverberated from the northeast rim of the basalt cliffs, their traditional nesting spot. From the canyon walls, the descending liquid songs of a canyon wren echoed around the bowl.

Bored stiff, I headed off trolling an orange seal leach and a green seal leach behind my full-sink line. I finned my way over to the island. One fisher was hooking up fish regularly by fishing chironomids on a very long leader in 20+ feet of water. I set up my chironomid rig in shallower water for a while, but I didn’t see any fishes cruising here either. Eventually, I started trolling again to @Cowlitzbottomfisher who had spent most of the late morning / early afternoon along the northern shore. I had what felt like one hit on the way but no additional action as I covered that area a few more times.

@Cowlitz Bottomfeeder told me that he caught two fish already. The first was on a chironomid under a float and the second was on a wooly bugger while trolling. I started out setting up to fish chironomids near him. But the fact that he had caught only two fish in this area didn’t indicate that the fishing was red-hot. He had stomach pumped a fish and it had eaten several olive and striped chironomids.
A03StomachPumpChironomids.jpg

I thought that I might retry a reliable spot again to see if there were fish there now. I trolled my way back by the peninsula with the full-sinking line and a pair of seal leaches, one orange and one olive.
A04GreenSealLeach_4090014.jpg

I thought that I hooked up some algae. As I was bringing in the sinking line by hand to remove the vegetation, an eager fish grabbed the fly only 10-15 feet behind the pontoon boat. It hooked itself and then went crazy. I was fighting it with the line in my hand. Fortunately, it wasn’t a huge fish. I managed to guide it to the side of my pontoon boat. But before I could slip the long-handled net under the fish, it jumped over the pontoon and into the space between them. Chaos followed with a tangle of line and fish until I was able to net the fish. It was about 14” but with a big body and a small head. That fish had been eating well since it has been planted in the lake.
A05ChubbyRainbow1bP3290011.jpg

I went back on the troll and hadn’t moved very far when I had another vicious takedown. This fish pulled hard right from the start. Between reeling and finning after the fish, I managed to bring this fish to the net. It was a dark-colored 18-20” fish. Both fish took the olive seal leach.
A06Rainbow2bP3290013.jpg

I anchored up in a spot where I had success in previous trips. The fishing wasn’t red-hot but I hooked and landed four nice rainbows on simple small black chironomid. My “philosophy” on chironomids is to use a small point fly, size 18 or so, that is very non-threatening and that a cruising fish might take as low risk snack.
A07SmallChironomid4090017.jpg

Two fish actually grabbed the point fly as I was lifting the line to reposition it.
A08Rainbow3bP3290027.jpg

A09Rainbow5aP3290033.jpg

A10MeHoldingTrout4.jpg
Day 1 went well.
Steve
 
“Stony Crossing”, 30 March 2022, Day 2 of 3
The forecast today was for a mostly sunny day increasing winds during the day with gusts in the afternoon and the forecast wa correct. It was windy at 10mph with gusts to 22mph in the afternoon. My friends and I opted to fish “Stony Crossing” rather than to fight the wind in our pontoons at "Arid Cataract Lake".

I am not sure what one of my friends was fishing, but I started with a Callibaetis parachute in the fast water exiting the pool opposite the middle camping spot. Even with the wind, I was getting good drifts, but no interest.

@Cowlitz Bottomfeeder was fishing an apricot egg pattern in the pool. It didn’t take long before he had a take. It was a very nice fish that fought hard
A01FightingTroutP3300071.jpg

before our other friend slipped it into the net.
A03NettingTroutP3300056.jpg

A02HoldingTroutP3300062.jpg

A short time later, he hooked another fish and this time I did the netting honors. The long-handled pontoon nets came in handy.
A04TroutWIthApricotEggFlyP3300072.jpg

At that point, my other friend borrowed an apricot egg and tried to do the same thing. But the fishes’ interests died down and except for a missed strike or two, @Cowlitz Bottomfeeder hooked nothing else here. Eventually, my friends headed off downstream to find greener pastures out of the wind. I continued to work over this riffle section with casts of my Callibaetis parachute or Quigley cripple. There were even some Callibaetis hatching in the shallows and a few swallows sweeping through.

Then @Cowlitz Bottomfeeder called me to say that there were fish rising in the section that they were fishing downstream. When I arrived, @Cowlitz Bottomfeeder was still fishing his apricot egg but without much success. My other friend was trying scuds near the bottom. I made a series of cast various Callibaetis options, but except for a single clear lookie-loo who made a clear refusal, no one was interested. And there were Callibaetis coming off. On rare occasions a fish would rise, typically far out of my casting range, but nothing sustained or consistent. Eventually, I just said screw it and made myself comfortable on the bank and watched the cruising fish. I suggested that @Cowlitz Bottomfeeder might try to fish chironomids (my boxes were in my pontoon boat…). And he actually caught two fish on chironomids.
A05HoldingRainbowb.jpg
About 5ish, we called it a day, windburned and dehydrated. Not the first time that I have had my butt kicked at "Stony Crossing"...

Steve
 

Attachments

  • A02HoldingTroutP3300062.jpg
    A02HoldingTroutP3300062.jpg
    335.3 KB · Views: 4
Back to “Dry Cataract Lake”, Day 3 of 3.
It would be a typical spring day on “Arid Cataract Lake”. There were sporadic winds in the 5 to 10mph through the day, increasing into the low teens in the later afternoon. The daytime temperatures were in the mid-50’s but it felt much colder when the sun ducked behind the scattered clouds. I was glad that I had on my Patagonia jacket. But the walls of the canyon lit up in the sunlight.
UmatillaRockP3310081.jpg

When the four of us arrived, there were three other cars at the launch. Of course, I started out where I had success on day 1. But it was very quiet this morning. Yet, there were lots of midges emerging, but no fish here. After some fruitless chironomid fishing, I then pulled out the streamer rod and finned my across the lake. I caught up to one of my friends under the north wall. He had a grab or two but he had not landed a fish yet.

I took several more 360o pics here; I was hoping that the vertical would come out great when modified into a tiny planet or a mirror ball and they did.
A02MirrorBall2.jpg
A03TinyPlanet3.jpg

And there were lots of midges emerging in this bay; I captured a few pictures.
A04HatchingMidgeP3310085.jpg

After this photographic interlude, I decided to continue trolling my way to the area below the Visitor Center. @Cowlitz Bottomfeeder had made a beeline there first thing in the morning. He had spoken to another angler in the campground who said that he had marked multiple fish in this region. I have done well there in trips later in the spring, both in deeper water and in the shallows. On the way, I lost my two streamer rig on a rock and had to retie. By the time, I made my way there to the west end, both of my friends had caught at least one fish (next 2 photographs courtesy of @Cowlitz Bottomfeeder).
A05WithNiceRainbow2.jpg
A06WithSilverRainbow.jpgA05

I started out with my chironomid rig at my maximum depth (about 12 feet), but not the 20+ feet that I suspect that I needed. I quickly lost patience and went back to trolling back to my original location. And when I arrived, the fish were there. I hooked three fish pretty quickly but lost all three of them during the fight. The last of the three took all the fly line off my reel and was into my backing as it made beeline into the reeds at the edge of the peninsula. I had to fin my way over to retrieve my line. As I closed on the reeds, I pulled on the fly line and that activated the fish which headed back out toward open water. But the fly line was wrapped around some of the reed stalks. The leader went ping and it was off.

But then my fortune changed. I hooked and landed four fish in a row. I encouraged them to run out into deeper, open water and completed the battle there.
A07Rainbow1eP3310115.jpg
A08Rainbow1fP3310116.jpg
A09Rainbow2bP3310130.jpg
A10Rainbow2cP3310137.jpg

So, it was a satisfying end to the annual "Arid Cataract" fishing adventure.

Steve
 
Last edited:
Excellent. Very nice report on fishing and other observations. Nice to hear the falcons are back. They are a treat and I love the sound when they stoop on prey. I have often heard them hunting before I saw them. Of course, I can do without the rwbb’s attacking my mirrors and pooping all over my truck.
 
“Stony Crossing”, 30 March 2022, Day 2 of 3
The forecast today was for a mostly sunny day increasing winds during the day with gusts in the afternoon and the forecast wa correct. It was windy at 10mph with gusts to 22mph in the afternoon. My friends and I opted to fish “Stony Crossing” rather than to fight the wind in our pontoons at "Arid Cataract Lake".

I am not sure what one of my friends was fishing, but I started with a Callibaetis parachute in the fast water exiting the pool opposite the middle camping spot. Even with the wind, I was getting good drifts, but no interest.

@Cowlitz Bottomfeeder was fishing an apricot egg pattern in the pool. It didn’t take long before he had a take. It was a very nice fish that fought hard
View attachment 11148

before our other friend slipped it into the net.
View attachment 11149

View attachment 11151

A short time later, he hooked another fish and this time I did the netting honors. The long-handled pontoon nets came in handy.
View attachment 11152

At that point, my other friend borrowed an apricot egg and tried to do the same thing. But the fishes’ interests died down and except for a missed strike or two, @Cowlitz Bottomfeeder hooked nothing else here. Eventually, my friends headed off downstream to find greener pastures out of the wind. I continued to work over this riffle section with casts of my Callibaetis parachute or Quigley cripple. There were even some Callibaetis hatching in the shallows and a few swallows sweeping through.

Then @Cowlitz Bottomfeeder called me to say that there were fish rising in the section that they were fishing downstream. When I arrived, @Cowlitz Bottomfeeder was still fishing his apricot egg but without much success. My other friend was trying scuds near the bottom. I made a series of cast various Callibaetis options, but except for a single clear lookie-loo who made a clear refusal, no one was interested. And there were Callibaetis coming off. On rare occasions a fish would rise, typically far out of my casting range, but nothing sustained or consistent. Eventually, I just said screw it and made myself comfortable on the bank and watched the cruising fish. I suggested that @Cowlitz Bottomfeeder might try to fish chironomids (my boxes were in my pontoon boat…). And he actually caught two fish on chironomids.
View attachment 11155
About 5ish, we called it a day, windburned and dehydrated. Not the first time that I have had my butt kicked at "Stony Crossing"...

Steve
No need to apologize about that hat and pants- lots of men are color blind.
 
Thanks for your great trip report; nice to see some quality fish!!
 
Very good report - nice to see some success at the lake as from what I have heard the last couple of years the reports have been dismal - thus the reason why you didn't have much company at the lake other than your group.

I am curious on getting other's opionion on how WDFW is managing the lake? I have heard that they reduced amount of fish they are stocking due to make it more of a "quality" over "quantity" fishery and concerns of the lake shrinking due to lack of water. My question is did they go too far in reducing the stocking - or would others like to see a few more fish stocked?

But with the result from this report - catching 4 or 5 of those pigs could be considered a succesful day and meet most alot folks of expectations of this lake (I would be pleased) so maybe this lake is back on the upswing and rebounding. But the last couple of years I am hearing that it has been extremely tough fishing - maybe too tough for whatever reason - but not that long ago I was catching some really nice fish and pushing double digit days catching 12+ fish in a day with plenty that are in 16 to 20 inch range. Are those days behind us for this lake?

Peach
 
Very good report - nice to see some success at the lake as from what I have heard the last couple of years the reports have been dismal - thus the reason why you didn't have much company at the lake other than your group.

I am curious on getting other's opionion on how WDFW is managing the lake? I have heard that they reduced amount of fish they are stocking due to make it more of a "quality" over "quantity" fishery and concerns of the lake shrinking due to lack of water. My question is did they go too far in reducing the stocking - or would others like to see a few more fish stocked?

But with the result from this report - catching 4 or 5 of those pigs could be considered a succesful day and meet most alot folks of expectations of this lake (I would be pleased) so maybe this lake is back on the upswing and rebounding. But the last couple of years I am hearing that it has been extremely tough fishing - maybe too tough for whatever reason - but not that long ago I was catching some really nice fish and pushing double digit days catching 12+ fish in a day with plenty that are in 16 to 20 inch range. Are those days behind us for this lake?

Peach
Personally, I like how the arid cataract lake is being managed. There are plenty of lakes in the Basin where one can go to catch 14-15" fish. I would rather have a chance at a few fish of 20 inches or so than the more typical trout from the likes of those lakes near Beverly. Just my opinion. In my drives by the arid cataract lake and looking at it from the observation site, I'd say Steve and his friends were lucky with the low number of other anglers. I've certainly seen more and experienced more fishers.

Be well.
Patrick
 
Last edited:
I also fall in the "as-is" camp. I suspect that if I was fishing chironomids at 20+ feet, I would have caught more fish (but I don't know if they would have been bigger on average). The first fish in the first post has a small head and a large body, indicating a fast growth rate.
Steve
 
this lake hasn't had a catchable stocking since 2001, so they're all feral. sharp contrast to the lakes near beverly which have received only "legals" since 2010 - but in much lower numbers. the state doubled the bows from 2004 to 2005 and maintained that as an average till 2012 when they cut the bows by 40%, then cut by another 20% of 2012 numbers in 2016, and that's about the numbers we're at now - which is also about where we were before 2005. the browns and tigers they haven't really messed with. i prefer what they're doing now, myself.
Thanks for the breakout of the recent stocking plan - this is very useful and provides some data around just the antidotal observations.

My thinking is that the sweet spot was the 2012 to 2016 plan - that was the time when I thought they had a good combination of quantity and quality where you could catch a variety of size classes but still have double digit days with several fish in the 16 inch to 20 inch category. But more people fishing the lake back then compared to the last three years or so. To each their own, as they say.

I can't speak to the Tigers and Brown stocking as I have not caught either a Brown or a Tiger yet in that lake :).

Peach
 
Back
Top