Real costs/experiences of an outboard repower?

Hard pass.

Tough to do, but good call to walk away. Unless the joy for you is in the project work as much as it is in the actual boating, that's a headache that you don't need.
The only way I’d be interested in this one is if I just bought the engine and the hull was free. Then I could run it (the hull) into the ground and not worry.

I’ve already passed on nicer versions of this hull with the wrong engine. Now it’s the other way around.
 
Just saw this not sure if it's your jam

I was looking at that one again earlier today but that layout isn't really my jam, nor is the asking price.

This one is more like it, although I'd still prefer an Outrage 17 v1 or an Outrage 18 as both are significantly lighter than the Montauk 170.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ffb
This one is more like it, although I'd still prefer an Outrage 17 v1 or an Outrage 18 as both are significantly lighter than the Montauk 170.
Pretty clean looking tho...
 
You try looking east coast? They seem both more common and more affordable.

I've purchased a cdory (Nashville) and Arima (Boston) and sent em both west. Savings were significant but stress did go up a little.

I have occasionally looked towards the East Coast and cried a bit at the plethora of options (relative to here) but that's about it. I'm a bit hesitant to buy something sight-unseen; years ago I flew across the country to buy a rare-ish vehicle without seeing it first based on the word and photos from the seller and ended up being unpleasantly surprised at the actual condition compared to advertised condition. So if I'm going to fly around and inspect potential options myself, then ship something west at a ballpark of $14k (per a couple estimates from boat couriers I got earlier this summer), any potential purchase price savings would be destroyed by transport costs.

I do somewhat regret not looking more seriously at a few options that came and went in Vancouver/Vancouver Island this summer. Oh well.
 
Those carriers are pretty high. I had mine towed back for about a 1/3 of that. Not on a flat bed, but tow behind. It was a while ago, but agreed, the 14k does destroy any savings.

Both of my experiences went as I expected. One private seller, other a dealer. I didn't see either of em til they showed up in my driveway. I wasn't expecting cherries though. Ended up selling the dory for a nice little bit and still fish the Arima.

Seems you are quite patient and prepared to move. I'm sure what you're looking for will show.
 
I'm still keeping my eyes peeled for the right option but figured I may use the collective experience here for some education on boat brands/styles that I'm not experienced with.

Seems like there are a lot of aluminum boat brands that have clones in the 18' range.

What's the difference between Hewes, Alumaweld, Alumacraft, Duckworth, Wooldridge, North River, etc. when it comes to something like this? I'm sure there are things like deadrise and so forth that might make one less poundy than another. I'm more looking for broader stroke brand differences/quality stuff like I asked about outboards earlier.

I will say that the Whaler Tax that I was prepared to pay is nothing compared to the aluminum tax on boats like these.

Duckworth-18-Advantage-5.Still002-2.jpg


AlumaweldTalon1.jpg


Green-Hewewscraft-Sportsman-Gallery-2.jpg
 
I'm still keeping my eyes peeled for the right option but figured I may use the collective experience here for some education on boat brands/styles that I'm not experienced with.

Seems like there are a lot of aluminum boat brands that have clones in the 18' range.

What's the difference between Hewes, Alumaweld, Alumacraft, Duckworth, Wooldridge, North River, etc. when it comes to something like this? I'm sure there are things like deadrise and so forth that might make one less poundy than another. I'm more looking for broader stroke brand differences/quality stuff like I asked about outboards earlier.

I will say that the Whaler Tax that I was prepared to pay is nothing compared to the aluminum tax on boats like these.

Duckworth-18-Advantage-5.Still002-2.jpg


AlumaweldTalon1.jpg


Green-Hewewscraft-Sportsman-Gallery-2.jpg
Construction and materials. An Alumaweld, which is made in high production numbers, will usually weigh hundreds of pounds less than a more custom build like a Duckworth in the same length/layout, which will feature heavier guage aluminum and more robust bracing. When I was running a 16' custom aluminum prop sled a decade back, the builders personal and last boat he constructed, it was #250 heavier than an Alumaweld 16' Super Vee with very similar dimensions, deadrise, etc. Which was why I replaced it with a first gen Clackacraft Magnum weighing a third of the sled= so much easier to manhandle.
Horses for courses, and sometimes more is actually less.
 
It has taken me 55 years to understand the term “buy once, cry once”. A few years ago I decided a boat would be in the plans. I searched the adds and saw all kinds of boats that would work. But they had 2 strokes, that are loud and harder to maintain. Trailers that never had their bearings maintenanced. Etc. you are buying 3 products. The boat hull. The engine. And the trailer. You need to look at all three independently that way. The boat doesn’t get to the lake without a good trailer. The boat doesn’t motor acrossed the lake without a good engine. And the useage will determine the kind of hull you want. It’s hard to call a tow truck when you are broke down on the water.
Good luck. I love my Lowe 1775 FM with 115hp merc.
Dave
 
I'm still keeping my eyes peeled for the right option but figured I may use the collective experience here for some education on boat brands/styles that I'm not experienced with.

Seems like there are a lot of aluminum boat brands that have clones in the 18' range.

What's the difference between Hewes, Alumaweld, Alumacraft, Duckworth, Wooldridge, North River, etc. when it comes to something like this? I'm sure there are things like deadrise and so forth that might make one less poundy than another. I'm more looking for broader stroke brand differences/quality stuff like I asked about outboards earlier.

I will say that the Whaler Tax that I was prepared to pay is nothing compared to the aluminum tax on boats like these.

Duckworth-18-Advantage-5.Still002-2.jpg


AlumaweldTalon1.jpg


Green-Hewewscraft-Sportsman-Gallery-2.jpg
Surfnfish kinda covered it. For the most part, you can't go wrong with any of those brands. They're all good in their own way. Alumaweld being the "budget" option, but they're still good boats. Hewes would be a step up, and I'd probably put Duckworth alongside them there. I think Hewes is probably best bang-for-buck in my experience. I actually had a Hewes 20' boat for one season before deciding I wanted two separate boats (one for ocean, one for Columbia). Father in Law had a 22' (24' with the offshore bracket) Alumaweld Intruder I used for tuna fishing for a few years before getting my fiberglass boat for that.

These boats are designed with PNW fishing in mind. While they're not exclusively used in this part of the world, they aren't particularly common anywhere else. These aluminum style boats are pretty unique to our part of the world and very much dialed for most of what we do. The windshield boats being the "jack of all trades."

I'd say if you want to fly fish out of it, look more into the open style, non-windshield boats. Much more freedom of movement, and easier to cast from the bow. Usually very easy to remove seats, too.
 
Back
Top