PFDs you'll actually wear

Evan B

Bobber Downey Jr.
Staff member
Admin
Sorry if this comes off as an ad.... I know I've posted a bit about these before, but really do think they're that good of a product. I've made suggestions to multiple fishing buddies with bad habits of not wearing their PFDs to get one of these, and all were instant fans as well. Just ask @Billy :D

So a few years ago, I picked up three of the NRS Chinook PFDs because I'd heard good things. I'd been using the inflatable type PFDs prior, and after a few mishaps and failures, and just not being a huge fan of them in general, I decided to get something else.

What I immediately liked was that once I put it on, I was totally fine keeping it on, which I'd never had happen with a PFD before. With all the pockets, it was basically like wearing a fishing vest. Most importantly, my guests were leaving theirs on as well.

1748521352637.png1748521411617.png

Downsides:

For me, if there was one, it was the zippers. As you can tell from my pics above, I was using them in saltwater quite a lot. On 2 of my 3 vests, the zippers on the pockets corroded and got stuck shut, eliminating one of my favorite features on them.

I found out NRS was making an update to them, so I looked into it to see what was changing. I was able to confirm that the zippers were indeed changing to address the issue I experienced. They also changed a few things with the cut/fit to be more form-fitting- according to the answers I received, mostly to eliminate "tenting" or spots where oars or paddles can get caught, which is definitely a thing I experienced with previous vests when rowing rivers. They have also apparently changed the foam type, but I don't foresee that being something most will notice.

Since I have two boats and was tired of climbing into my bigger boat to grab the PFDs every time I needed them in my small boat, I ordered three of the new PFDs recently, and moved my old models to my small freshwater boat. I purchased one of the Chinook OS version, and two of the standard Chinook. As far as I'm aware, the main difference is in the pocket configuration.


Here is the new (left) and old (right) version of the standard Chinook PFD.
1748521955358.png

(new)
1748521983350.png

(old)
1748522012303.png

You can see some differences in materials, as well as shape, especially in the back/shoulder area.
1748522036935.png


Exterior-wise, not worlds apart different. If you can find the old version on closeout and don't plan on getting it salty, it's a hard deal to beat. But getting the new version is absolutely worth it as well if it's something you end up actually wearing.
 
Last edited:
Sorry if this comes off as an ad.... I know I've posted a bit about these before, but really do think they're that good of a product. I've made suggestions to multiple fishing buddies with bad habits of not wearing their PFDs to get one of these, and all were instant fans as well. Just ask @Billy :D

So a few years ago, I picked up three of the NRS Chinook PFDs because I'd heard good things. I'd been using the inflatable type PFDs prior, and after a few mishaps and failures, and just not being a huge fan of them in general, I decided to get something else.

What I immediately liked was that once I put it on, I was totally fine keeping it on, which I'd never had happen with a PFD before. With all the pockets, it was basically like wearing a fishing vest. Most importantly, my guests were leaving theirs on as well.

View attachment 155141View attachment 155142

Downsides:

For me, if there was one, it was the zippers. As you can tell from my pics above, I was using them in saltwater quite a lot. On 2 of my 3 vests, the zippers on the pockets corroded and got stuck shut, eliminating one of my favorite features on them.

I found out NRS was making an update to them, so I looked into it to see what was changing. I was able to confirm that the zippers were indeed changing to address the issue I experienced. They also changed a few things with the cut/fit to be more form-fitting- according to the answers I received, mostly to eliminate "tenting" or spots where oars or paddles can get caught, which is definitely a thing I experienced with previous vests when rowing rivers. They have also apparently changed the foam type, but I don't foresee that being something most will notice.

Since I have two boats and was tired of climbing into my bigger boat to grab the PFDs every time I needed them in my small boat, I ordered three of the new PFDs recently, and moved my old models to my small freshwater boat. I purchased one of the Chinook OS version, and two of the standard Chinook. As far as I'm aware, the main difference is in the pocket configuration.


Here is the new (left) and old (right) version of the standard Chinook PFD.
View attachment 155145

(new)
View attachment 155146

(old)
View attachment 155147

You can see some differences in materials, as well as shape, especially in the back/shoulder area.
View attachment 155148


Exterior-wise, not worlds apart different. If you can find the old version on closeout and don't plan on getting it salty, it's a hard deal to beat. But getting the new version is absolutely worth it as well if it's something you end up actually wearing.
I”m a fan as well and have the old version. Don’t use it in saltwater or get tuna slime on mine. I have a NRS whitewater vests for my drift boat. They frequently have sales on their PFDs. I’ll have to get another Chinook or two as well for my aluminum fishing boat. I fish the Hanford Reach and am often the only person at the river with a PFD on. My guests often comply because I’m wearing mine. Thanks for posting the information on the differences.
 
I”m a fan as well and have the old version. Don’t use it in saltwater or get tuna slime on mine. I have a NRS whitewater vests for my drift boat. They frequently have sales on their PFDs. I’ll have to get another Chinook or two as well for my aluminum fishing boat. Thanks for posting the information on the differences.
I personally have only ever worn their Chinook, but my wife got one of their Ninja PFDs to use on her SUP, and is a fan of that one as well. They just seem to have the PFD thing dialed, which is a main reason for this post as so many people say they rarely wear one because they're "too bulky" or any other valid complaint on most PFDs.
 
I will 3rd(?) the chinook. I have one and wear it when I'm on my kayak regardless of the water and whenever I'm floating in my watermaster. Just wore it for an entire day on Mayfield and didn't even notice it was on. Last year floating the Sandy there were multiple days I just forgot to take off the PFD once I got out of the raft and kept fishing with no issue.

The best PFD is the one you'll wear.
 
Since the day I put on my first Chinook I have never been on the water without it. It changed my lake fishing routine by forcing me to evaluate how much crap I carried in a vest and now instead of 5 fly boxes with over a thousand flies, I carry two that fit in the Chinook and notice that I seldom use more than a dozen flies in a given day anyway.

Last year the wife of a long time engineering friend decided she wanted to start fishing lakes having been fishing only streams since she was a little girl. She asked for help to get started not really knowing what all to buy at the outset. She came up to fish with me for a week and I gave her a new Super Fat Cat, fins and of course a Chinook vest. She took to lake fishing immediately and proved herself competent and a self starter catching a shit load of fish. Back again last week we had some excellent days on the water with her hooking some 20''+ rainbows at times and looking stylish in her bright red Chinook.

The feature I like most about the Chinook is the high mounted flotation on the back that doesn't interfere with the back of a seat in a float tube or pontoon boat. It makes for all day comfort in the saddle without being pitched forward by a bulky vest. About $100-$150, most of us are worth at least that much....
 
+1 for the Chinook. I wore mine SUPing yesterday! I’ve also experienced the salt corrosion but so far no catastrophic damage… yet.
 
Hmmm. May have to look into these. I wear mine, which is the inflatable (lakes only for me) and never notice it while wearing it, but there's always that sliver in the back of my mind about reliability with regard to deployment.
 
Since I'm mostly wearing mine while rafting its the Ninja for me. Its going to take some pretty decent water to get me to fall off that barge so I want something I can swim a rapid in. The large arm holes and lack of clutter are also nice for rowing. I wear the same while sailing. The big arm holes are really nice when pulling sheets and the smaller but thicker pads keeps it out of my way.

One more consideration for all boaters: If you go in the drink, somebody is going to have to pull you out. Solid shoulder straps are super important as thats the easiest thing to grab. Its dam hard even in a low profile sailboat or raft, I can't imagine doing it ona powerboat with some serious freeboard. You guys ever try it on a warm day? Rear platforms are nice but trying to get somebody there in rough seas(when you would fall over) ain't easy.
 
The improved pliers retention strap might be reason enough on its own for me to upgrade.
 
They also changed a few things with the cut/fit to be more form-fitting- according to the answers I received, mostly to eliminate "tenting" or spots where oars or paddles can get caught, which is definitely a thing I experienced with previous vests when rowing rivers. They have also apparently changed the foam type, but I don't foresee that being something most will notice.
Have you noticed the oars snagging the PFD still? Or did they fix the tenting issue?
Drives me crazy when oars snag the pfd...
 
I find it easy to wear the Chinook. Started just to set an example for the grand kids, but it's just comfortable and like I said before, now it's like a helmet on a bike, feel naked without it.
Others will go through a lot of grief and trauma if one of us drown. We can take some precautions to limit that possibility by wearing a PDF. Comfort or vanity don't quite stack up to grief.
 
Have you noticed the oars snagging the PFD still? Or did they fix the tenting issue?
Drives me crazy when oars snag the pfd...
Rowing is no longer part of my boating/fishing game the past couple years, so I can't say for sure. I definitely notice that these are more form-fitting along the back and sides than the old model though.
 
Don’t forget one for your dog as well.
Yup. Ruffwear makes several great canine PFDs (I personally outfit Mabel with the Float Coat).

(Disclaimer: The company founder is a friend of mine – my dogs have beta tested a LOT of the gear they offer. But Patrick is also a great guy and fly fisherman himself, and the company is dedicated to keeping active outdoor dogs safe!)
 
Back
Top